Warrington Town's record in English Amateur Cup The table below shows the club's league record, including top appearance maker and goalscorer each season (league games only). Please be aware that appearance data is incomplete prior to 1999.
| Date | Opponent | Comp | Att |
Result | Warrington Scorers | | | 18/09/1954 | Manchester University (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 4-1 | Foster (3 goals), Rudge | Details |
| 02/10/1954 | Newton (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-2 | | Details |
| 01/10/1955 | I.C.I. Alkali (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 1-1 | Rothwell | Details |
| 08/10/1955 | I.C.I. Alkali (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 4-1 | Foster (2 goals), Bennett, Arnold | Details |
| 15/10/1955 | Hoylake Athletic (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 2-3 | Bennett, Rothwell | Details |
| 29/09/1956 | Port Sunlight (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 2-2 | Bennett, Hunt | Details |
| 06/10/1956 | Port Sunlight (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 4-3 | Foster (4 goals) | Details |
| 13/10/1956 | Stoneycroft (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 5-1 | Bennett, Hunt (2 goals), Foster (2 goals) | Details |
| 27/10/1956 | Runcorn Athletic (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 2-4 | Foster (2 goals) | Details |
| 28/09/1957 | Whitchurch (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-4 | | Details |
| 27/09/1958 | Earle (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 4-0 | Berrington (2 goals), Lockett, Own Goal | Details |
| 11/10/1958 | Northern Nomads (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 1-1 | Berrington | Details |
| 18/10/1958 | Northern Nomads (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 4-1 | Berrington (2 goals), Green, Own Goal | Details |
| 25/10/1958 | Middlewich (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 3-1 | Lockett, Tipping, Own Goal | Details |
| 08/11/1958 | I.C.I. Alkali (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 1-4 | Berrington | Details |
| 26/09/1959 | Stork (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 1-1 | Lambeth | Details |
| 03/10/1959 | Stork (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 1-0 | Whelan | Details |
| 10/10/1959 | Shell (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 3-0 | Lambeth (2 goals), Rowlinson | Details |
| 24/10/1959 | Newton (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 3-3 | Lambeth (2 goals), Whalley | Details |
| 31/10/1959 | Newton (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-4 | | Details |
| 01/10/1960 | I.C.I. Alkali (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-0aet | | Details |
| 08/10/1960 | I.C.I. Alkali (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 1-4 | Lightfoot | Details |
| 30/09/1961 | Guinness (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 1-1 | Richards | Details |
| 07/10/1961 | Guinness (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-1 | | Details |
| 29/09/1962 | Newton (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-1 | | Details |
| 28/09/1963 | Moreton (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 1-1 | Sealey | Details |
| 05/10/1963 | Moreton (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 2-1 | Pearson, Sealey | Details |
| 12/10/1963 | Guinness (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 1-5 | Bennett | Details |
| 26/09/1964 | Old Altrinchiams (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-1 | | Details |
| 25/09/1965 | Middleton (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 5-1 | Grayson (2 goals), Winter, Abbott (2 goals) | Details |
| 09/10/1965 | Liverpool Univ (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 4-0 | Winter (2 goals), Abbott, Payne | Details |
| 23/10/1965 | Guinness (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-1 | | Details |
| 23/09/1967 | Ashville (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-2 | | Details |
| 1970/1971 | Chloride (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 1-1 | Gleave | Details |
| 1970/1971 | Chloride (H) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-1 | | Details |
| 1971/1972 | Knowle (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-2 | | Details |
| 1972/1973 | Lostock Gralam (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-1 | | Details |
| 1973/1974 | Wythenshawe (N) | E.A.C.EAC | | 0-0 | | Details |
| 1973/1974 | Anson Villa (A) | E.A.C.EAC | | 2-4 | Wright, James | Details |
* = Won on penalties
^ = Lost on penalties | 
