Warrington Town's record in Mid-Cheshire League Challenge Cup The table below shows the club's league record, including top appearance maker and goalscorer each season (league games only). Please be aware that appearance data is incomplete prior to 1999.
| Date | Opponent | Comp | Att |
Result | Warrington Scorers | | | 02/09/1953 | Runcorn Athletic (H) | MCLC | 800 | 2-0 | Arnold, Leigh | Details |
| 13/03/1954 | Altrincham Reserves (H) | MCLC | | 5-0 | Martin, Rothwell (2 goals), Corlett, Arnold | Details |
| 14/04/1954 | Nantwich Town (A) | MCLC | | 6-0 | McMutrie (2 goals), Corlett, Rudge, Robinson, Hayes | Details |
| 28/04/1954 | Goostrey (N) | MCLC | | 3-0 | Arnold, Hayes, Melbourne | Details |
| 13/09/1954 | Middlewich (H) | MCLC | | 4-1 | Martin, Hayes, Tipping, Foster | Details |
| 13/11/1954 | Wilmslow (H) | MCLC | | 4-3 | Owens (2 goals), Tipping, Foster | Details |
| 29/04/1955 | Lostock Gralam (N) | MCLC | | 4-3 | Foster (3 goals), Banner | Details |
| 06/05/1955 | I.C.I. Alkali (N) | MCLC | | 2-1aet | Rothwell (107, 111) | Details |
| 01/09/1955 | Wilmslow (H) | MCLC | | 10-2 | Foster (3 goals), Rothwell (3 goals), Arnold (2 goals), Woods, Martin | Details |
| 17/09/1955 | I.C.I. Alkali (A) | MCLC | | 2-2 | Arnold, Foster | Details |
| 12/11/1955 | I.C.I. Alkali (H) | MCLC | | 4-2 | Foster (2 goals), Rothwell, Bennett | Details |
| 21/04/1956 | Middlewich (A) | MCLC | | 5-3 | Foster (2 goals), Hunt, Rothwell, Arnold | Details |
| 21/08/1956 | Goostrey (H) | MCLC | | 11-2 | Bennett (2 goals), Tipping (4 goals), Hayes (2 goals), Owens, Banner, Martin | Details |
| 29/08/1956 | Linotype (A) | MCLC | | 5-2 | Tipping (3 goals), Hunt (2 goals) | Details |
| 24/11/1956 | Whitchurch (H) | MCLC | | 2-0 | Green, Tipping | Details |
| 19/01/1957 | Nantwich Town (N) | MCLC | | 5-3aet | Hunt (2 goals), Green, Bennett, Hayes | Details |
| 02/05/1957 | Runcorn Athletic (N) | MCLC | | 1-2aet | Tipping | Details |
| 03/09/1957 | Altrincham Reserves (H) | MCLC | | 6-1 | Bennett (2 goals, 1 pen), Green, Grayson (2 goals), Tipping | Details |
| 12/10/1957 | Barnton (H) | MCLC | | 4-1 | Tipping (3 goals), Banner | Details |
| 29/04/1958 | Linotype (H) | MCLC | | 0-3 | | Details |
| 02/09/1958 | Wilmslow (A) | MCLC | | 6-0 | Berrington (4 goals), Own Goal, Bennett | Details |
| 21/02/1959 | Knutsford (A) | MCLC | | 2-2 | Prytherch, Rowlinson | Details |
| 13/04/1959 | Knutsford (H) | MCLC | | 4-1 | Robinson, Foster, Berrington, Hunt | Details |
| 27/04/1959 | Runcorn Athletic (H) | MCLC | | 3-2 | Rowlinson, Hayes, Berrington | Details |
| 07/05/1959 | I.C.I. Alkali (N) | MCLC | | 1-2 | Foster | Details |
| 26/08/1959 | Barnton (A) | MCLC | | 3-1 | Robinson, Rothwell, Bennett | Details |
| 07/09/1959 | Wilmslow (H) | MCLC | | 3-1 | Hayes, Morris, Whelan (pen) | Details |
| 07/11/1959 | Lostock Gralam (H) | MCLC | | 4-1 | Hunt (2 goals), Wheat (2 goals) | Details |
| 05/03/1960 | Knutsford (A) | MCLC | | 0-3 | | Details |
| 05/09/1960 | I.C.I. Alkali (A) | MCLC | | 1-1 | Cameron | Details |
| 14/09/1960 | I.C.I. Alkali (A) | MCLC | | 0-0 | | Details |
| 26/11/1960 | I.C.I. Alkali (H) | MCLC | | 2-2 | Hayes (pen), Bennett | Details |
| 31/12/1960 | I.C.I. Alkali (A) | MCLC | | 1-0 | Own Goal | Details |
| 04/02/1961 | Runcorn Athletic (A) | MCLC | | 4-2 | Murphy, Tipping, Swift (2 goals) | Details |
| 04/03/1961 | Witton Albion Reserves (H) | MCLC | | 0-1 | | Details |
| 13/09/1961 | I.C.I. Alkali (A) | MCLC | | 0-1 | | Details |
| 12/09/1962 | Barnton (A) | MCLC | | 3-1 | Sealey, Arnold, Grayson | Details |
| 08/04/1963 | Moulton (A) | MCLC | | 5-3 | Sealey (2 goals), Bennett (pen), Grayson, Nelson | Details |
| 08/05/1963 | I.C.I. Alkali (N) | MCLC | | 0-3 | | Details |
| 28/08/1963 | Crewe Alexandra A (A) | MCLC | | 1-2 | Bennett | Details |
| 26/08/1964 | Knutsford (A) | MCLC | | 4-2 | McKune (2 goals), Swain, Winter | Details |
| 09/09/1964 | Middlewich (H) | MCLC | | 1-3 | Payne | Details |
| 19/03/1966 | Middlewich (H) | MCLC | | 1-3 | Ormson | Details |
| 01/09/1966 | Sandbach Ramblers (A) | MCLC | | 1-1 | | Details |
| 04/03/1967 | Sandbach Ramblers (H) | MCLC | | 2-2 | Gerraghty, Morris | Details |
| 29/03/1967 | Sandbach Ramblers (A) | MCLC | | 3-1 | Winter, Gerraghty, Darbyshire | Details |
| 05/04/1967 | Congleton Reserves (H) | MCLC | | 1-1 | Ellison | Details |
| 19/04/1967 | Congleton Reserves (A) | MCLC | | 2-1 | Hardy, Own Goal | Details |
| 06/05/1967 | Lostock Gralam (A) | MCLC | | 2-6 | Evans, Cartledge | Details |
| 29/08/1967 | Winnington Park (H) | MCLC | | 2-0 | Pearson, Miller | Details |
| 11/09/1967 | Middlewich (H) | MCLC | | 5-3 | Cartledge, Hardy, Miller, Evans (2 goals) | Details |
| 27/01/1968 | Eastwood Town (A) | MCLC | | 0-10 | | Details |
| 12/08/1968 | Whitchurch (H) | MCLC | | 1-3 | Own Goal | Details |
| 13/08/1969 | Rylands (A) | MCLC | | 2-6 | Bleasedale, Long | Details |
| 1970/1971 | Alsager (H) | MCLC | | 0-1 | | Details |
| 1971/1972 | Kidsgrove Athletic (A) | MCLC | | 1-6 | McCullum | Details |
| 1972/1973 | Linotype (H) | MCLC | | 1-2 | Groarke | Details |
| 1974/1975 | Winnington Park (A) | MCLC | | 2-1 | McCormack, Hardy | Details |
| 1974/1975 | Barnton (A) | MCLC | | 1-2 | Gleave | Details |
| 1975/1976 | Congleton (H) | MCLC | | 0-3 | | Details |
| 1976/1977 | Kidsgrove Athletic (A) | MCLC | | 1-2 | Brown | Details |
| 1977/1978 | U.S.C. Sale (A) | MCLC | | 2-1 | Monteith, Woods | Details |
| 1977/1978 | Bramhall (H) | MCLC | | 4-1 | McCormack, Woods, Monteith, Monteith | Details |
| 1977/1978 | Prescot Town (A) | MCLC | | 1-5 | Woods | Details |
* = Won on penalties
^ = Lost on penalties |
