Warrington Town's record in North-West Counties League Challenge Cup The table below shows the club's league record, including top appearance maker and goalscorer each season (league games only). Please be aware that appearance data is incomplete prior to 1999.
| Date | Opponent | Comp | Att |
Result | Warrington Scorers | | | 04/09/1982 | Chadderton (H) | NWCCC | | 4-2 | Dolan, Davies (2 goals), Stokes | Details |
| 13/11/1982 | Eastwood Hanley (H) | NWCCC | | 4-0 | Reid, Daniels, Davies, Hughes | Details |
| 05/03/1983 | Lancaster City (A) | NWCCC | | 1-1 | Hughes | Details |
| 12/03/1983 | Lancaster City (H) | NWCCC | | 1-0 | Hughes | Details |
| 09/04/1983 | Prescot Cables (H) | NWCCC | | 2-1 | Dolan, Monteith | Details |
| 23/04/1983 | Darwen (A) | NWCCC | | 0-3 | | Details |
| 10/09/1983 | Daisy Hill (H) | NWCCC | | 6-1 | Peters, Hughes, Hill, Daniels (2 goals), Monteith | Details |
| 24/12/1983 | Prescot B.I. (A) | NWCCC | | 1-1 | Reid | Details |
| 02/01/1984 | Prescot B.I. (H) | NWCCC | | 0-2 | | Details |
| 08/09/1984 | Padiham (H) | NWCCC | | 5-0 | Cook, Hughes, Gratton, Price (2 goals) | Details |
| 10/11/1984 | Droylsden (A) | NWCCC | | 0-1 | | Details |
| 1985/1986 | Wren Rovers (H) | NWCCC | | 3-1 | King, Kinsey (2 goals) | Details |
| 14/09/1985 | Wren Rovers (A) | NWCCC | | 1-1 | Clark | Details |
| 1985/1986 | Ford Motors (A) | NWCCC | | 3-1 | Hughes, Kinsey (2 goals) | Details |
| 1985/1986 | Formby (H) | NWCCC | | 3-0 | Williams, Hughes, Mather | Details |
| 28/03/1986 | Accrington Stanley (H) | NWCCC | 181 | 3-2 | Kinsey, Hughes (2 goals) | Details |
| 12/04/1986 | Rossendale (H) | NWCCC | | 2-1 | Price, Hunter | Details |
| 19/04/1986 | Rossendale (A) | NWCCC | | 3-3 | Hughes (2 goals), Vernon | Details |
| 01/05/1986 | Clitheroe (N) | NWCCC | | 2-0 | Hughes, Price | Details |
| 1986/1987 | St Helens Town (A) | NWCCC | | 1-4 | Hughes | Details |
| 23/08/1986 | Formby (H) | NWCCC | | 1-0 | Whittingham | Details |
| 03/10/1987 | Atherton LR (H) | NWCCC | | 5-0 | Hughes (2 goals), Kinsey, Lowe, Harvey | Details |
| 21/11/1987 | Rossendale (H) | NWCCC | | 2-1 | Lake (2 goals) | Details |
| 27/02/1988 | Leyland Motors (A) | NWCCC | | 1-0 | Hughes | Details |
| 12/03/1988 | St Helens Town (H) | NWCCC | | 3-1 | Barton, Hughes (2 goals) | Details |
| 19/03/1988 | St Helens Town (A) | NWCCC | | 1-0 | Kinsey (42) | Details |
| 12/05/1988 | Colwyn Bay (N) | NWCCC | | 3-1 | Barton (20), Hughes (25, 79) | Details |
| 22/10/1988 | Glossop North End (A) | NWCCC | | 1-1 | Williams | Details |
| 19/11/1988 | Glossop North End (H) | NWCCC | | 2-0 | Hughes, Hodge | Details |
| 04/02/1989 | Maghull (A) | NWCCC | | 1-1 | McClatchey | Details |
| 11/02/1989 | Maghull (H) | NWCCC | | 3-1 | Harvey, Kinsey, Hodge | Details |
| 11/03/1989 | Leyland Motors (H) | NWCCC | | 2-1 | Hodge (2 goals) | Details |
| 01/04/1989 | Clitheroe (A) | NWCCC | | 0-0 | | Details |
| 08/04/1989 | Clitheroe (H) | NWCCC | | 2-0 | Kinsey, Hodge | Details |
| 04/05/1989 | Colwyn Bay (N) | NWCCC | | 0-3 | | Details |
| 11/11/1989 | Chadderton (H) | NWCCC | | 4-0 | Hughes (3 goals), Hodge | Details |
| 03/03/1990 | Salford City (A) | NWCCC | | 2-0 | Hughes, Hodge | Details |
| 17/03/1990 | Nantwich Town (H) | NWCCC | | 3-1 | Devaney (2 goals), Hodge | Details |
| 31/03/1990 | Leyland Motors (H) | NWCCC | | 1-0 | Devaney | Details |
| 07/04/1990 | Leyland Motors (A) | NWCCC | | 5-1 | Coulson, Hodge, McClatchey, Hughes (2 goals) | Details |
| 26/04/1990 | Knowsley United (N) | NWCCC | | 2-2^ | Hughes, Tandy | Details |
| 18/10/1997 | Atherton LR (A) | NWCCC | | 2-0 | Berry, Birch | Details |
| 06/12/1997 | Skelmersdale United (A) | NWCCC | | 1-3 | McGhee | Details |
| 26/09/1998 | Ashton Town (H) | NWCCC | | 5-0 | Whitehead (2 goals), Ward (2 goals), Dack | Details |
| 24/10/1998 | Vauxhall (H) | NWCCC | 92 | 2-3 | Tyrell, Whitehead | Details |
| 09/10/1999 | Ashton Town (H) | NWCCC | 49 | 1-0 | Bushell | Details |
| 27/11/1999 | Squires Gate (A) | NWCCC | 35 | 1-4 | Priedt | Details |
| 14/10/2000 | Darwen (A) | NWCCC | 56 | 0-4 | | Details |
| 03/11/2001 | Norton United (A) | NWCCC | 72 | 3-1 | Moore, Morgan, Ingle | Details |
| 01/12/2001 | Cheadle Town (H) | NWCCC | | 5-2 | Chadwick (2 goals), Moores (2 goals), Morgan | Details |
| 08/01/2002 | St Helens Town (A) | NWCCC | 125 | 0-3 | | Details |
| 02/11/2002 | Chadderton (H) | NWCCC | 75 | 3-0 | Pick, Heverin, Moore | Details |
| 14/12/2002 | Salford City (H) | NWCCC | 78 | 0-2 | | Details |
| 01/11/2003 | Nelson (H) | NWCCC | 72 | 1-1 | Mitchell | Details |
| 04/11/2003 | Nelson (A) | NWCCC | 60 | 2-1 | Webster, Mitchell | Details |
| 06/12/2003 | St Helens Town (A) | NWCCC | 88 | 3-4 | Webster, Heverin (2 goals) | Details |
| 04/02/2004 | Woodley Sports (A) | NWCCC | 71 | 1-0 | Mitchell | Details |
| 27/03/2004 | Bacup Borough (A) | NWCCC | 80 | 1-4 | Heverin | Details |
| 03/04/2004 | Bacup Borough (H) | NWCCC | 85 | 2-3 | Heverin, Baker | Details |
* = Won on penalties
^ = Lost on penalties |
